For some of the most active women of color authors on Twitter, The 1619 Project creator and journalist Nikole Hannah-Jones ripped Joyce for using an anonymous source and wanting โto be oppressed so badly.โ Romance novelist Courtney Milan reminded us that Joyce told fantasy YA author and publisher Dhonielle Clayton in 2017 โto start her own publishing company if she felt excludedโ and added that Joyce is a โracist.โ
Joyce doubled down in another tweet, saying, โThis is what is most astonishing about writers like Rimbaud, Keats, Hemingway, Carson McCullers, John Cheever, John Updike–they began writing well so young, & some might argue that their strongest writing was their earliest.โ So, sheโs implying publishing overall is in trouble because in her opinion the industry is losing its brightest stars, which historically have been overwhelmingly White male.
All this hoopla is swirling as Netflix announced its film adaptation of Joyceโs 2000 biographical fiction book Blonde, based on the life of Marilyn Monroe. The press around the film, which is expected to be available for streaming later this year, seems to be unaffected by the #BookTwitter controversy.
Publishing her first novel in 1963, Joyce, now 84, has written 58 books with five of those, including Blonde, becoming finalists for the Pulitzer Prize. Though sheโs considered an industry treasure, her off-the-cuff remarks in relation to diversity, equity, and inclusion reached a height with this recent fiasco.
Banned books across the political and racial spectrum are causing concerns. The NYT op-ed that was referenced in Joyceโs Twitter argument mentions how books featuring and written by Black and queer authors are seeing bans across the country while former Vice President Mike Penceโs book deal saw protests from Simon & Schuster employees.
Dana Canedy, who recently stepped down as S&S publisher, stood her ground to support Penceโs book though sheโs Black. As a journalist, she knew that the Trump administration officialโs story as well as stories by Black nonfiction authors are needed to fight censorship.
While there is data on how people of color are largely underrepresented as publishing industry employees and as authors and illustrators, the data is not showing any issues with White male authors not being given book deals. If you look at most literary agencies where the majority of agents are usually White female, almost their entire clientele is White with other dominating identities such as cisgender, heterosexual, Christian or atheist.
Diversity, equity, and inclusion is an overarching problem; the only thing now is the underrepresented groups in publishing are louder in their fight for equality and balance thanks to social media. Bookstores may be prioritizing books by people of color and by LGBTQIA+ authors in the front of their windows now because they never had done that before. At the end of the day, itโs the publishing industryโs duty to make sure all stories, if well-balanced and fair, are published to represent all readers.
Saying you heard from your friend in the industry that an unproven trend is happening is not helpful to the discourse. At least, wait for the data to prove the trend, then we can have that conversation on censorship.